National Library of New Zealand
Harvested by the National Library of New Zealand on: Oct 10 2008 at 0:43:58 GMT
Search boxes and external links may not function. Having trouble viewing this page? Click here
Close Minimize Help
Wayback Machine
GayNZ Logo & Link
Friday 10 October 2008


Law report: "Repeal Gay Panic Defence"

Posted in: New Zealand Daily News
By GayNZ.com News Staff - 26th October 2007

Latest News
AUS: 'Lesbian fertility' Bill passes
Up-late Aussie TV viewers get Kiwifruit
More voices needed for Wellington Helpline
AUS: Donor "impregnated 30 lesbians"
Former Mr. Gay UK "killed & ate lover"
AKL City Council shuts down LGBT Forum
Waipouri's sister wants tougher sentencing
Priest in trouble over 'tattoo gays' comment
Church marks 10 yrs since Shepard murder
The Chop:Lots of haircuts,no HIV-poz results
Family bar seeks talent on Wednesdays
Takataapui dancers set for Akl Town Hall
New group for Waikato gay & bi girls
Sean Penn texted Madonna about gay kiss
Gay issues in Vice-Pres debate (+VIDEO)
$15K prize pool for Queen of Universe show
Free haircuts today after K' Road HIV test
Week of events builds Hamilton Pride
Gay couple features in winning short story
Melissa Etheridge makes wedding plans

Gay Labour MP Charles Chauvel says he welcomes today’s call by the Law Commission to remove the 'Gay Panic Defence' from NZ law.

The Defence, contained in section 169 of the Crimes Act 1961, allows a murder defendant to claim that he was the object of sexual advances by the victim, and found these advances so offensive that he was driven to murder in a psychotic state. If the defence is accepted, the murder charge is reduced to manslaughter.

A-crowd-gathers.jpg
Wellington rally to abolish Gay Panic Defence in May 2007
There must be some – but need not be much – evidence of provocation before a judge lets a jury consider whether it should be available as a defence. The threshold test that the judge has to apply is extremely low, points out Chauvel.

Around 100 people met at bucket fountain in Wellington's Cuba mall to rally against Section 169 back in May.

“Section 169 of the Crimes Act 1961 must be repealed,” Law Commission President Sir Geoffrey Palmer said today.

‘Gay Panic Defence' is a shorthand label, not an accurate legal description. But as the Law Commission recognises, it is one of the main ways that the provocation defence operates. Of the four known cases in the past five years when the provocation defence has been pleaded successfully, two have involved the ‘Gay Panic Defence'.

“We do not believe that such circumstances offer a valid excuse for murder," said Sir Geoffrey.

“More broadly, and more importantly, intentional killing in anger in any circumstances is inexcusable. Section 169, as interpreted by the courts, requires the defendant to have demonstrated the self-control of an ordinary person. But even when very angry, no ordinary person responds to any provocation by deliberately killing. That is an extraordinary and inexcusable response.”

“If provocation is repealed, only one thing will change for defendants who would formerly have relied upon it. They will be convicted of murder instead of manslaughter. That is all that a partial defence achieves.”

Chauvel praised the Law Commission report, which he said was carefully researched. "It notes that in the half-dozen other jurisdictions over the past 30 years where this issue has been considered by a law reform body, the provocation defence has been abolished.

"I will be writing to the Minister of Justice to urge that the Law Commission's recommendations be accepted," says Chauvel.



Ref: Charles Chauvel, Law Commission (m)